Patreon vs Buy Me a Coffee vs Spotify fees

The short version

Sources read September 2026: Patreon pricing, Buy Me a Coffee’s fee breakdown, Spotify’s fee schedule, Spotify’s eligibility rules and Stripe’s published rates.

The same 10% twice, meaning opposite things

Put the two pricing pages side by side and the parallel is exact. Spotify’s fee schedule gives the charge from 20 October as a “Platform fee: 10% (includes payment processing fees, foreign exchange fees, and payout fees)”. Patreon’s pricing page gives its charge as “10% of the income you earn on Patreon”, followed immediately by “Plus payment processing, currency conversion, and payout fees, and applicable taxes”.

Payment processing, foreign exchange, payout fees. Payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees. Three for three, in the same order, on opposite sides of the total. One page is quoting a finished number and the other is quoting a starting one, and nothing about either presentation tells you which you are looking at unless you read the sentence underneath.

This is not a claim that Patreon conceals anything — the qualifier sits directly below the number, in Patreon’s own words. It is a claim about what the number is good for. A headline percentage in this category tells you the most you can keep, and on exactly one of these platforms it also tells you the amount.

The part that cannot be resolved is how much Patreon’s three extras come to. Its help centre returns HTTP 403 to us on every fee article, so the rates are not readable at source, and the only honest figure we can give for Patreon is a ceiling: no more than 90 cents in the dollar, by an amount Patreon does not publish anywhere we can reach.

What each headline actually covers

Buy Me a Coffee publishes all four surcharges on its own fee page; we have applied each to the gross transaction, which it does not state explicitly. Its Stripe figure matches Stripe’s own published “2.9% + 30¢ per successful transaction for domestic cards”. Ko‑fi is absent rather than free: its help centre also returns 403, so we could not read its rates — see below.

The 5% that costs more than the 10%

Buy Me a Coffee is the one platform here that looks obviously cheapest and is not. It states a “5% platform fee per transaction, which means you get to keep 95% of your earnings”, and then lists the rest: Stripe’s “2.9% + $0.30 per successful transaction”, a “0.5% fee for payout processing”, “+1% for international (outside of the US) transaction” and “+0.5% for subscription payments”.

A recurring membership bought from outside the US triggers every one of those. That is 9.9% in percentages plus a flat 30 cents — and 9.9% is not meaningfully below Spotify’s all‑in 10%, which means the entire difference between the two platforms is the fixed fee.

Our arithmetic on the published rates, for a recurring membership from outside the US: 5% + 2.9% + 0.5% + 0.5% + 1% = 9.9%, plus $0.30. A domestic recurring tier drops the 1% and runs 18.9% at $3 and 14.9% at $5. Spotify publishes no fixed per‑transaction fee, so its column is flat.

Read the last two columns together and the ranking never inverts at any price a membership is realistically sold at. Setting the two formulas equal, Buy Me a Coffee only becomes cheaper than a flat 10% above $300 a month per supporter for a recurring international tier, or above $27.27 for a domestic one. On a one‑off domestic tip the crossover falls to $18.75, which is the one case where the 5% headline behaves like a 5% headline.

The 30 cents that decides it

The thing driving all of that is not a percentage. A fixed 30 cents is 10% of a $3 pledge on its own, before any platform takes anything. At $5 it is 6%, at $10 it is 3%, and at $25 it is 1.2%. These platforms are named and priced around the cost of a coffee, and the payment rails underneath them are priced for a shopping basket.

Which produces the most useful number on this page. Moving a Buy Me a Coffee tier from $3 to $10 takes the all‑in cost from 19.9% to 12.9% — a 7 point saving. Switching from Buy Me a Coffee to Spotify at $5 saves 5.9 points. The lever entirely inside your control is bigger than the one that involves migrating your audience to a different platform.

It is also the same shape as something this site keeps finding. The Payoneer annual fee is charged only to accounts receiving under $6,000 a year, and payout thresholds trap money for exactly the creators with the least of it. A fixed cost against a variable base always falls hardest on the smallest amount, and in this category the smallest amount is the default.

What the cheapest number costs you

Spotify having the only all‑in figure does not make it the answer, and two things narrow it sharply.

The first is that it is not open. Spotify requires “at least 2 published episodes and an audience of at least 100 Spotify users in the last 30 days”, and lists roughly 33 eligible countries. Patreon and Buy Me a Coffee apply no audience test at all. It is also podcast‑only, so for most of this site’s readers the comparison is really Patreon against Buy Me a Coffee and the flat 10% is a benchmark rather than an option. Our Spotify podcast monetization page covers that gate and the $10 payout minimum in full.

The second is what you own afterwards. Patreon’s pricing page lists “Exportable email lists” among the things the 10% buys. A membership that lives inside Spotify is a relationship with Spotify’s audience, on Spotify’s terms, and this site has written enough about owning a list to think a few points of fee is a reasonable price for being able to leave. Worth noting too that Patreon’s own pricing page advertises “Spotify integration and Synced Feeds”, so the two platforms with identical headline numbers and opposite meanings are built to work with each other.

And the 10% is new. Until 19 October the Spotify charge is a 5.5% processing fee plus FX of 0.8–1.6% where it applies, so a creator with no conversion at all is going from 5.5% to 10% — about 82% more. Spotify states that legacy subscriptions migrated across keep the old arrangement “until the subscriber cancels”, which makes a supporter signed up before the date permanently worth more than the same person signed up after it.

What we would actually do

Raise the tier before changing the platform. At $3 the fixed fee alone is taking 10% and no platform choice on this page recovers that; at $10 it is taking 3%. A single $10 tier is worth more than three $3 tiers on every set of rates we read, and it is the one decision that does not require anybody to re-subscribe anywhere.

After that the choice is mostly not about fees. If you make a podcast, clear Spotify’s bar and want the simplest possible number, the flat 10% from 20 October is the only figure in this category that is final — and if you have existing subscribers, they are cheaper where they are. If you want an email list you can take with you, Patreon publishes that as part of what you are buying, and its 10% ceiling is competitive even before you know the extras. Buy Me a Coffee is the one we would think hardest about, because its headline is the lowest and its all‑in cost is the highest at every tier under $50.

The general rule is duller than the comparison suggests: in this category the advertised percentage tells you almost nothing until you find the sentence about what sits outside it. Two of the three pages here put that sentence directly under the number. One of them puts nothing there because there is nothing to add.

What we could not verify

• Patreon’s processing, conversion and payout rates. The single biggest gap here. Its help centre returned HTTP 403 on every fee article, so no Patreon figure beyond the 10% headline appears above. Third parties put the all‑in cost at 13–16%; we have not repeated those numbers because we could not read them at source.
• Patreon’s legacy plans. Its pricing page presents a single 10% with no tiers named and no distinction between new and existing creators. Third parties describe older 5%, 8% and 12% plans and a November 2026 migration deadline. None of that is asserted above.
• Ko‑fi, entirely. It belongs in this comparison and its help centre also returns 403. It is missing from the table rather than confirmed to charge nothing.
• What base Buy Me a Coffee applies its surcharges to. It lists four charges without saying whether each is calculated on the gross. We have applied them all to the gross, which is the straightforward reading, and every figure in that table depends on it.
• Spotify’s base. The old fee is described against subscription payments and the new one as “deducted from net earnings”, and Spotify does not reconcile the two. Treat the 5.5%‑to‑10% comparison as one of published percentages rather than identical amounts.
• Anything about enforcement or timing. Every figure here is published wording. We have not run a membership, taken a payout or checked a statement on any of the three.

FAQ